top of page

Lemony Gem - Favorites Collection

  • May 3, 2025
  • 2 min read

Updated: Aug 26, 2025

CHARACTER(S): "Lemony Gem" (secret Lemon Hearts)

RELEASE DATE: 2012

PLACE OF PRODUCTION: China

MANUFACTURING COMPANY: ?

TYPICAL PRICE ONLINE: $30 - $40 USD ($150 - $350 in box)

  • Collector/trade value is generally considered to be around $35

OTHER COMMENTS/INFO:

Release Info:

  • This pony is from a Collector's Series - She was part of the Toys R Us Exclusive Collectors Set, the Favorites Collection, which additionally included Nightmare Moon, Flower Wishes (Daisy), Rainbow Dash, DJ Pon 3 (Vinyl Scratch), Pinkie Pie, and Trixie Lulamoon. It originally sold for $39.99

    • This toyset was marketed towards adult collectors, evident in the highlighting of fan favorite characters / background ponies + The two most popular mane 6 members in the online fandom

    • Part of why this set is desirable is because Nightmare Moon, Trixie, Vinyl Scratch, and Daisy were not featured in a lot of merchandise, especially in the mane series


General Info:

  • She has the raised hoof pose, which is uncommon for Classic G4 brushables, and generally makes a brushable more popular/sought-out

    • This, combined with this being her only release, and her having a unique look to her, pushes the brushable's price up


Comments:

  • I've always been annoyed about Lemony Gem, because she's just Lemon Hearts from FiM, but with a different cutie mark and slightly different name. Apparently though, there's a background pony named Lemony Gem who has Lyra's hairstyle and a more pastel-toned version of Lemon Hearts color scheme. I still call BS. She doesn't even have a visible cutie mark, all the pictures of her she's wearing a saddle. I think people just found a pony with a similar enough color scheme to excuse this, but I say no! This is just Lemon Hearts. And if I ever find her (which I plan to) I will paint over her cutie mark, as God intended! What do they have against Lemon Hearts!

Image sources:

See also:


Comments

This website is purely for educational/archival purposes. I do not own the rights to My Little Pony, and most photos on this site are not my own. I provide image sources if the source is still available online, but there are far too many photos for me to ask each person for permission (and some are from users who are inactive or not possible to contact -- i.e., from sites like Worthpoint) - The whole point of the site is collecting as many photos as possible. I try to ask permission on social media or forums that I'm active on, especially if I'm using a lot of photos from one person. If you own one of the photos on this site and do not want it here, message me and I will remove it. This isn't meant to take credit from or upset anyone; It is just for fun and to help record the existence of these toys. If you are made uncomfortable by me using your photos, I will remove them for you.

bottom of page